We've reached the end of the road in the NHL postseason, and it's time for my final series prediction of the spring. Given the magnitude of the series, my prediction will be more in-depth than the previous rounds, so let's take a look at how the Western Conference Champion Edmonton Oilers match up against their counterparts from the East, the Carolina Hurricanes, in all the key areas, after which I'll make the big call on who will walk away with the Stanley Cup.
Stanley Cup Final(2) Carolina Hurricanes vs. (8) Edmonton OilersBetween the PipesAfter watching the Canes operate a carousel of netminding throughout the first three rounds, one would have to think that this time it's going to be all Cam Ward unless something goes horribly amiss. He's not only been better than Gerber, but he's been better than every other goalie he's faced to this point (except for
maybe Ryan Miller, who was excellent). He might be young, but he's proven that he can play huge games and make them look like a cakewalk, and it's my own opinion that we could be seeing the emergence of one of the NHL's elite big-game goaltenders here in 2006.
Nearly two-hundred feet away will stand a man that has paid his dues at every level, and has piqued later in his career than most netminders. Dwayne Roloson has long been a great AHL goaltender, and was also a great NHL goaltender in his time with Minnesota. He is one of the strongest mental goalies the league has ever seen, and is the battler between the pipes that Edmonton has sorely needed since Curtis Joseph left. He's acrobatic, quick, and smart, and he didn't come all this way just to earn a contract extension. Roli wants the Cup.
So who's got the advantage? My money is on Edmonton here, as much as I like and respect Cam Ward. Roloson is tougher mentally and physically, and he is playing like a man possessed right now. Carolina is going to have to work to get pucks past the Oilers' stopper, and if the way the West was won is any indication, that work might be too much for any team of mere mortals right now.
Advantage: Edmonton OilersDefenseCarolina's back end is anchored by some solid hockey players with lots of experience. Mike Commodore, Bret Hedican, Aaron Ward, Niclas Wallin and Glen Wesley have all played in a Stanley Cup Final before, which means that five of the top six D for the Canes know what's coming. That said, nobody on that list is in the category of 'offensive dynamo', and their most offensive-minded defenseman is Frankie Kaberle, who is notorious for coughing up pucks in his own end and/or making generally bad decisions with the biscuit. Also, while the blueline in Carolina has experience, nobody on the list is a true horse that can be relied on every night to play big minutes and shut down the opposition himself. Defense by committee is fine by me, but I think I'd rather have one big-minute guy and a committee of five than have six guys who all look like they should be playing on any other team's second pairing.
The Oilers' blueline is shockingly similar to that of the Hurricanes, with one
big exception. Chris Pronger. Pronger is playing better now than he did in his Hart Trophy season in 2000, logging huge minutes and absolutely dominating whoever he's matched up against. Along with Pronger, hockey's greatest warrior directs the Edmonton defense corps, that man being Jason Smith. They call him 'Gator' because of his unusually reptilian feet, but they could easily call him Gator because he's ornery and tough and likes to prey on people who come into his territory. Add to the mix guys like Jaroslav Spacek and the other great warrior, Steve Staios, as well as a solid third pairing in Matty Greene and M-A Bergeron, and the Oilers have a mix that could be the recipe for success.
As far as an advantage goes, I'll once again have to grant it to Edmonton. I like Pronger's presence, especially when he's out there with Smith, and the other two pairs are more talented than Carolina's bottom-four, even if they do lack the same experience. It's a closer call than goaltending is, but Edmonton has the advantage on the blueline.
Advantage: Edmonton OilersForwardsUp front Carolina is quick and deep with the like of Staal, Stillman, Weight, Recchi, and Williams. There's also a great deal of defensive conscience there with the Adams boys and Selke trophy nominee Rod Brind'Amour, so both ends of the ice will be secure. The Canes can score a lot in a short period of time with all this talent, and given that the fourth line has yet to record a point between them in the postseason you might see a hero born via a timely marker. The only downside is that sometimes the forwards get too cute with the puck and end up paying the price for it, but that doesn't happen enough to be a major concern.
Edmonton's forwards are a real mix of what playoff hockey is all about. They're fast, mean, physical, and fairly skilled, and are committed to playing a full sixty minutes every night. They don't make many mistakes, they are the picture of keeping it simple, and they are absolutely lethal on faceoffs. They'll look to wear Carolina out with a hard-hitting forecheck and then get pucks to the net for deflections or jam plays, so Cam Ward can expect to get well-acquainted with the number 94, because it will be in his face for this entire series.
While it's hard to go against guys like Smyth and Horcoff, it's easier when you look at the host of talent on the Canes' roster. I don't think Carolina is faster, but they are definitely more skilled and probably better overall in the two-way sense. I know what to expect from both clubs up front, and I think it's a great matchup for Edmonton, but I also think that Carolina has the edge by a small margin.
Advantage: Carolina HurricanesPowerplayCarolina's powerplay is not as good as the numbers suggest. They scored five powerplay goals on Jersey in the second round, which inflated their numbers grossly, and have since been more or less anemic on the powerplay. For my money, this is where the forwards' tendency to get too cute has hurt them, as they have fallen in the trap of "one too many passes" on more than one occasion in the postseason. With that said, there is more talent among the five guys the Hurricanes can ice than most teams have on a full roster, so don't let it shock you if they really get rocking out of nowhere in this series.
Edmonton is essentially the exact opposite of Carolina on the powerplay. They have been consistently pounding pucks on goal and maintaining extensive possession during most man advantages. They went on a run in which seven of eight games included an Oilers' PP goal, and are looking to carry that over to the Final. Much like other aspects of their game, they keep it simple with shots from Pronger, Bergeron, or Stoll and look for deflections and rebounds, which is basically what they'll continue to do until the Cup is decided.
To me, this is another close call, and as much as I like Edmonton's simplicity, it still scares me how quickly Carolina can explode with all that talent. It comes down to whether you favour consistency over explosiveness or vice versa, and for me I think I'm going to have to take explosiveness.
Advantage: Carolina HurricanesPenalty KillingCarolina has very good penalty killing with Kevyn Adams, Rod Brind'Amour, and Justin Williams, and those defense-first blueliners they have add nothing but positives. They're good on faceoffs, they make fast, smart decisions with the puck, and they know how to grind it out. Cam Ward is back there for any lapses, which are not exactly frequent as it is.
The Oilers, however, are superhuman on the penalty kill. They will block shots with their faces if that's what it takes to kill a penalty, and on many occasions they have done exactly that. They do a good job of clearing lanes of vision for Roloson to see shots from the point, and every team that has faced Edmonton so far has had problems breaking down the Oilers' box because it is so mobile and so well-adjusted to every powerplay look they see. Led by Mike Peca and Shawn Horcoff, there is a real threat of shorthanded scoring chances because of the ability to read plays and adjust, which makes the Edmonton PK a tough nut to crack.
Long story short, Edmonton has a big advantage here. I have a lot of respect for Carolina's grinders and how they kill penalties, but the Oilers were
born for this stuff and that gives them a sizeable advantage in this area of the game.
Advantage: Edmonton OilersCoachingCarolina is a well-coached hockey club, especially for the type of talent they have and the way the NHL is operating nowadays. Peter Laviolette has his club firing on all cylinders, playing an up-tempo style that is filled with calculated risks and end to end action, and he's respected by people league-wide for his accomplishments this season. He's a player's coach, and shows emotion on the bench to match what his boys are feeling, which is nice to see. Expect him to have the Canes well prepared.
On the other bench, Craig MacTavish is doing exactly what Laviolette is, just with more of a defensive conscience. He preaches puck movement and speed, but also dump-ins and shot blocking - things that made him a great NHLer. The players love him and he's become a media darling for his tendency to say what he's thinking on anything and everything related to his hockey club. He runs his bench intelligently and knows what it takes to win the big one from his time as a player, so you can expect his boys to also be quite ready to go.
Despite the fact that some people may try and sell it that coaching doesn't make a difference when the stakes are this high, nothing could be further from the truth. The wrong matchup or a misread video during a session can lead to a total debacle, as can a coach who cannot properly motivate his players. So, although Peter Laviolette is a great coach (especially in this brave new world of wide open hockey) and may well win himself a Jack Adams award within the next month, I think the edge has to go to Craig MacTavish. He's been there before, he knows what it takes to win, and he's a smart coach. In a Stanley Cup Final, his words of wisdom aren't hollow nonsense or hot air, they're truth because he's done it before. He won't oversell his own experience to his players, and he won't make a show of them if they aren't adequately contributing, but he'll coach the way one needs to if they want their name on the Cup, and to me that's a major advantage.
Advantage: Edmonton OilersThe Conn Smythe WinnerIf it's Carolina that ends up with the Stanley Cup at the end of this series, it's a two horse race with a distant third man in the mix. As good as Eric Staal has been, I think he's going to come in second, and I think Cory Stillman is a guy with an outside shot due to his penchant for scoring big goals. However, to me, I don't see how you could vote against Rod Brind'Amour. He's been the heart and soul of the team, scoring big goals, winning big faceoffs, and making all the smart veteran plays that a captain should at this time of year. When the stakes are this high, a team needs a guy like Brind'Amour more than anything else, and he's deserving of the Conn Smythe should it end up in the hands of a Hurricane.
If the Cup goes to the Oilers, I think it's a similar situation as far as the race for the Smythe goes - a two horse race with a distant third. That distant third, to me, is Ryan Smyth, who has embodied playoff hockey during this run and has been a true leader for the Oil all the way. When the race tightens to those two horses, however, I think it will be Chris Pronger who edges out goalie Dwayne Roloson for the award. As fabulous as Roloson has been, Pronger is averaging over thirty minutes a game and is playing at a pace of nearly a point per game, which is incredible for a defenseman. He plays in all situations, and plays
well, never getting ruffled despite being a major target of forecheckers and always making the smartest play that's available to him. I love what Roli has given the Oilers in these playoffs, but for me I like what Pronger has given them just a tiny bit more.
My Picks: Rod Brind'Amour (CAR)/Chris Pronger (EDM)The 2006-07 Stanley Cup ChampionSo with all of this considered, the only question that remains is
who is to be this year's Stanley Cup Champion? This is it in a summary:
Carolina is a fast, skilled team that has solid goaltending and alright special teams. They aren't physical at all, but they are heady enough to stay out of trouble and will produce enough offensive opportunities to stay in any game they play, thanks to their all-out approach.
The Oilers are every bit as fast as the Hurricanes, they have a goaltending advantage, and better penalty-killing (the powerplay is pretty close, too). They'll keep it simple, and they will absolutely beat Carolina into the ice physically, while playing their own brand of intelligent, safe hockey.
To me, when these two teams meet, it's going to result in the Edmonton Oilers winning their first Stanley Cup since 1990. As good as Carolina are, Edmonton has been slaying Goliath all spring, simply a different incarnation every couple of weeks. I think Edmonton can hang with Carolina in every area that the Canes excel in, and I don't think the same is true in reverse. Edmonton can play a skating and skill game, but I'm not sold that Carolina can play a physically demanding, mucky style of game. I'm of the mind that we're fixing to see a real beauty of a series here, most likely a six- or seven-gamer, but if Edmonton had this clinched by the fifth game I would not be surprised in the least.
Prediction: Edmonton wins series 4-2So that's it for my massive Stanley Cup blowout. It took me a long time to consider the major points of a series and weigh out who had the advantages where, but after all the consideration I'm confident in my assessment of how this one breaks down. To any who are wondering, the clock is now ticking on my last blog entry for a while, I'm looking at two more entries and then finishing up for the summer. So suck it in now while it's new, because once the Final is over I'm on summer vacation! Thanks for reading folks, I'll be back with fresh post next Friday.
The Opinion Blog of Matthew Ryder